Homepage

Enders Analysis provides a subscription research service covering the media, entertainment, mobile and fixed telecommunications industries in Europe, with a special focus on new technologies and media.

Our research is independent and evidence-based, covering all sides of the market: consumers, leading companies, industry trends, forecasts and public policy & regulation. A complete list of our research can be found here.

 

Rigorous Fearless Independent

The Financial Times

28 September 2010

In an interview with Gavin Patterson, Chief Executive of BT Retail (Sleeping giant wakes up to technology), the Financial Times observed that BT Vision "has not tackled its rivals impressively since launching in 2006. With fewer than 500,000 subscribers, it missed its initial target of 2m-3m".  The article also revealed that BT's average revenues per broadband customer were declining in the company’s first quarter, due to discounting. Ian Watt was asked for his view.

The Financial Times

28 September 2010

In an article which revealed an upturn in UK regional newspaper property advertising (Johnston buoyed by property ads), the Financial Times quoted an optimistic Johnston Press which predicted that the "total advertising revenues [should] fall less than 3 per cent in the third quarter of 2010, compared with a nadir of 32.7 per cent declines in the depth of the recession last year".

Douglas McCabe was asked for his view. He said: “It’s hard to share Johnston’s optimism that job or property advertising are going to improve or even stay flat in the next year.”

Late entrant Bouygues Telecom is gaining broadband market share via the quad play. Orange and SFR have now also launched quad plays, but Iliad’s mobile offers will be ready only in 2012

Iliad hopes to use its new Freebox to energise recruitment around new IPTV services in Q4 2010. SFR will also launch a new box

Led by a likely VAT hike for triple play bundled IPTV services in 2011, triple play pricing is set to rise after many years, from €30 to €35/month. FTTH upgrades in urban areas will be gaining visibility this winter

Google’s new Google Instant displays and updates results in real time as users type in queries, shaving an estimated 2-5 seconds off the average 9 seconds taken to carry out a search

Available in the US and UK now and key European markets shortly with other territories and mobile to follow in 2011, Instant will help Google to differentiate its search engine in an increasingly competitive market

Google Instant should stabilise, if not boost, the company’s share of queries, which has fallen both in the US and globally since February, and may also enhance the value of ads on Google

The unlimited mobile data plan, rightfully credited with being a key part of the current boom in handset-based mobile internet use, is now being scaled back across the US and UK, with capped data bundles of various sizes now preferred

The economics of data are such that current price plans (including unlimited ones) combined with current average smartphone data usage rates are still respectably profitable for the mobile operators on an incremental basis, provided they do not substitute for the far more profitable voice and text messaging services

However, current average smartphone usage rates are around 1/50th of home broadband usage rates, and smartphones’ improving screens, increased storage capabilities and faster processors are enabling some users to push well beyond profitable usage levels, leading to the danger that average usage may surge in the future (possibly even within current 2 year contract periods), to the point where current plans are not profitable

Usage caps are therefore probably a long term necessary evil to guard against this risk, but mobile operators need to be sympathetic to most consumers having no idea how much data various activities might use, and protect them against the bill shock that might result from out-of-bundle charges

Apple: ecosystem upgrade

14 September 2010

Apple has upgraded its iPod family and also iTunes, which now includes new social networking features, and revamped Apple TV, now reinvented as a streaming-only device at a fraction of its former price

We expect iPod sales volumes to continue to slide despite the update, but estimate that improved ARPU will add $600 million to Apple’s topline in FY2011. However, iPhones and Macs are the company’s key revenue drivers

The revisions to Apple TV should drive up sales, but the content offering remains weak (especially outside the US) and it is joining an already crowded playing field – its main benefit is likely to be supporting the Apple ecosystem

 

A newspaper pay wall subscriber is worth only a quarter to a third of a print buyer: even if every single print buyer is successfully converted to the pay wall, newspapers will still face a basic problem of scale

Pay walls will not be able to compensate for lower revenue per reader by expanding the audience for paid news, due to the long term decline of circulation, free online news, 24-hour broadcast news and free-sheets

Future change will be radical: publishers may need to consider producing a newspaper its loyal readers recognise and value with just 200 rather than 500 journalists

The bounce back in TV NAR (Net Advertising Revenue) now looks set to continue into Q4, resulting in full year- on-year growth of about 12.5%

The bounce back has more than reversed the -11% fall in 2009, although it still leaves TV NAR in 2010 about -5% below pre-recessionary levels in 2007 (nominal prices). Meanwhile, persistent worries about the economy and the impact of government debt reduction measures suggest flat growth in 2011

Much depends in 2012 on the outcome of Ofcom’s review of the airtime minutage quota and distribution rules, where its own commissioned econometric analysis suggests that harmonisation efforts leading to increases in airtime supply could cause large reductions in TV NAR

Part Two of our annual report on classifieds covers property, auto (used) and directories

As with recruitment, covered in Part One, a step change downwards has occurred in the underlying volumes of transactions driving classifieds in property, autos and directories

Publishers of commercially-run classified sites must contend to different degrees with the presence of Google

Advertiser interest in print editions of directories will remain as these continue to attract mainly older consumers and households outside urban areas

Advertisers face a fragmented marketplace online for directory services, as desktops are used for in-home services, while smartphone apps supply the destination services prized by the affluent, young urban dweller