The UK altnets collectively lost over £1bn in 2023, with most metrics unrealistically distant from what they need to be for a sustainable model, particularly the smaller retail-focused operators.

Consolidation is essential for survival, and CityFibre at least has a reasonable case for long term sustainability with a wholesale model and Sky as a customer, and looks the most viable altnet consolidator in our view, with VMO2/nexfibre able to pick up the pieces should the sector fail.

A lack of long-term viability and related financing difficulties will dramatically slow network roll-out, reducing the altnet pressure on the rest of the sector even if consolidation improves penetration levels.

In the next fixed line regulatory review—TAR 2026—Ofcom is likely to maintain light regulation on Openreach’s pricing levels, while also maintaining strict restrictions on its pricing structures, which both help altnets. 

On other matters, none of the interested parties (Openreach/altnets/ISPs) look like getting exactly what they want, but by and large the industry will likely get what it needs—regulatory stability with a broadly pro-investment slant.

The next TAR in 2031 is likely to be more dramatic, but by our estimates, even a full return to cost-based charging will not result in significant wholesale price cuts, which is likely to be a relief to longer term investors in BT and the altnets alike.

This report is free to access

We view the CMA's proposed remedies to the Vodafone/Three merger as workable, but not necessary.

While acknowledging the reassurance that short-term pricing commitments can provide, we are of the view that going too far risks distorting a highly competitive market.

Aggressive MVNO pricing commitments, in particular, could amplify a significant drain on the operators' capacity to invest, threatening the network promises that the companies are making.

The spatial computing ecosystem is on the uptick with the wider availability of head mounted devices (HMD). Apple and Meta’s commitment to developing HMDs is existential to conquer the enormous technical hurdles these devices continue to face. 

Apple has chosen to maroon the Vision Pro with a lack of controllers and other design choices making it reliant on mostly passive entertainment. In total contrast, Meta’s deep engagement in gaming and 3D experiences showcases the potential for the HMD category.

Live sports is the outstanding use case for TV experiences on VR headsets, with exclusive NBA VR programming on Quest bringing new levels of immersion and presence, while gaming, and its developers, will still remain the dominant driver for VR and MR for the rest of the decade.

Service revenue growth dropped off by 2.7ppts this quarter, and into negative territory, as operators in all markets suffered weaker growth
 

Operators in France and the UK implemented price increases this quarter but re-contracting absorbed any positive revenue impact. In Italy, regulatory intervention thwarted operator plans to raise prices
 

Increasing competitive intensity in France and Germany comes at a time when operators can ill-afford ARPU dilution and high churn
 

SpaceX and its Starlink satellite network have made headlines dangling a vision of free emergency service coverage direct to all mobile devices, undoubtedly connected to its ongoing battles for FCC approval.

Starlink is the clear leader in the D2D space and almost certainly will be the first to launch its service. AST Space Mobile, backed by various mobile operators (including Vodafone) is lagging significantly behind, having not yet launched any commercial satellites.

The UK is however a relatively unfavourable geography for D2D, due to its high latitude and relative density, and we don't expect any launch of commercial service in the UK by Starlink or AST Space Mobile before 2026.

Service revenue growth dropped off by 5ppts this quarter to -1% as lower in-contract price rises hit.

The outlook for 2025 is marginally brighter than it was last quarter as new price-increase regulations raise the average in-contract price increase for customers.

The CMA is set to deliver its preliminary findings on the Vodafone/Three merger in September. If it is not approved, we expect both parties to significantly change their strategies to be viable in the UK market.

If the Vodafone/Three merger is blocked we envisage a significant cost reduction push from Vodafone, with a highly uncertain path to acceptable returns.

H3G's capex would need to more than halve from 2022 levels to get its finances onto anything like a reasonable footing. A commensurate scale-back of its network, and commercial, ambitions would also be required.

With H3G likely to enact a slow walk from the UK under such a scenario via a hybrid MNO/MVNO strategy, the UK would end up with three nationwide mobile networks either way, just lower quality ones if the deal is blocked—with a real cost to consumers and the government's growth agenda.

CityFibre has announced a deal to supply the second largest UK ISP Sky with wholesale broadband services, doubling its addressable target market at a stroke, in a blow to Openreach.

This may be just a foot in the door for CityFibre, but it is a critical one, and puts it firmly in the driving seat for altnet consolidation. There are also positives for VMO2 and other altnets hopeful of an eventual wholesale deal with Sky, and for retail ISPs now that the altnet sector is pitching towards wholesale away from retail.

While this is obviously bad news for Openreach, we see it more as an absence of a potential positive than something that might actually worsen current trends, and there are mitigating positives for the wider BT Group.

Market revenue growth was just positive at 0.2% in Q2, as lower price increases were mitigated by some temporary ARPU gains.

Growth is likely to drop negative in the rest of year however, with continued weak volume growth compounded by temporary ARPU gains unwinding.

Pricing structures differ quite widely as regards landline offers and out-of-contract pricing, and all could benefit from adopting best practice, a marginal gain worth pursuing in a tough market.