BT’s recent protests against the very high “government-inflicted” costs in the UK versus other countries likely relate to business rates, which are already sky-high by European standards and set to rise further.

The business rates reform has some worthy aims in providing some permanent relief for shops and pubs, but at the expense of discouraging much-needed investment in utilities and telecoms by dramatically inflating the cost.

Telecoms business rates also discourage investment by being hard-to-predict, and are distortive between competitors with dramatic differences in unit costs, with these issues partially addressable through valuation reform.

Most regulations within the TAR26 condoc were continuations of the previous pro-investment regulations, albeit with little progress made on copper withdrawal, no extra help for the struggling altnets and a number of unexpected twists at the margin. 

Within the detail, the most significant hit is the return of cost-based price controls to some leased line charges, and across all of the proposed changes, Openreach has on balance fared worse than retail ISPs, albeit at a scale that is manageable within the BT Group.

Ofcom showed no inclination to offer any extra help to the struggling altnet industry, regarding its inefficiencies as being its own (and its investors’) problem, with consolidation the only sensible path forward for most.